Rust Shooting Charges Against Alec Baldwin. Analysis w/ NY Criminal Defense Attorney David Schwartz on CBS 2 NY

Gotham
In The News

At Gotham Government Relations, we take pride in staying ahead of the curve when it comes to policy developments and current events that impact our esteemed clientele and team members. "Gotham In The News" is your go-to page for comprehensive coverage of news articles and videos that directly pertain to our areas of expertise.

0:00
all right this is a complicated and
0:01
emotional case here to help us
0:03
understand the legal development is New
0:04
York criminal defense attorney David
0:06
Schwartz who you just saw in that piece
0:07
a second ago by Ali Bauman and filmmaker
0:10
Laura Pellegrini to give us a little
0:11
perspective thank you both for taking a
0:13
few minutes to join us here thank you
0:14
David I'm going to start with you here
0:16
um explain the charges and why two
0:17
counts of involuntary manslaughter
0:20
yeah so you have two counts of
0:22
involuntary manslaughter which is really
0:24
based on this negligent standard did did
0:27
uh Alec Baldwin act as a reasonable
0:30
person in would act in that situation so
0:33
you have the one based on a negligence
0:36
standard and then there's an enhancement
0:38
where it's more of a reckless standard
0:41
but it's because he's handling a gun so
0:44
it's engaging in a lawful act so he was
0:48
engaging in a lawful act but he was
0:50
acting with this sort of extreme
0:52
negligence and because he was handling a
0:55
gun in that act that's where the
0:57
enhancement comes so the jury will be
0:59
given either the regular involuntary
1:02
both the involuntary manslaughter and
1:04
the enhancement and they'll have to
1:06
choose between the two the regular and
1:08
voluntary has a year and a half Max the
1:11
enhancement is five years now David also
1:13
the the New Mexico chief medical
1:15
investigator linked to the manner of
1:17
death as a quote accident now what will
1:18
the prosecutor have to do to prove in
1:21
order for there to be a conviction here
1:23
well it is an accident that's where you
1:26
have this fine line between is this a
1:28
civil case
1:31
or Arena so it's an accident I don't
1:34
think anyone is accusing Alec Baldwin of
1:36
intentionally firing the weapon and
1:38
killing this this person so bottom line
1:42
is uh even though it's an accident if if
1:46
the accident happened where Alec Baldwin
1:49
was acting with extreme negligence in
1:51
the entire situation not just the firing
1:54
of the weapon but the entire scene it
1:56
sounds like it was a scene where there
1:58
were multi multitude of negligent acts
2:01
and so if they can find that then Alec
2:03
Baldwin can be guilty and David there
2:05
was a settlement that was already paid
2:06
correct
2:07
right so unusual the civil case was
2:10
settled before the criminal case yeah
2:12
well no one knew there would be a
2:14
criminal case yeah I think that's why
2:15
this was that came as such a surprise
2:16
yesterday when these charges were handed
2:18
down Laura let me bring you in now
2:19
what's the reaction been from the film
2:21
Community following yesterday's
2:23
announcement
2:24
certainly a mixed reaction Chris you
2:26
know um I know the Santa Fe DA office
2:28
has done a really thorough investigation
2:30
independently to try to get to the
2:31
bottom of this this has been going on
2:33
for 16 months
2:35
um it's a blurry line you know Baldwin
2:36
he was a co-producer and he was an actor
2:38
in the project he didn't necessarily
2:41
oversee all aspects of production so he
2:44
chose that very fine line you know I
2:46
think at the end of the day we have to
2:48
ask ourselves did he violate protocol
2:50
and on any set that Stefano defray my
2:52
co-director and I have worked on there's
2:54
a very clear line of command you have a
2:57
prop master who hands the gun to an
2:59
armorer a licensed professional and they
3:01
in turn have to check the firearm to
3:04
make sure that it's a cold gun then it
3:06
gets handed to the assistant director
3:07
and they're tasked with the
3:09
responsibility of declaring a cold gun
3:11
to the actor before they use it so in
3:14
that circumstance you know Alec Baldwin
3:16
his responsibility was to trust the line
3:18
of command that took place on that day
3:20
yeah so let me ask you this this so
3:22
that's your protocol and the prosecutors
3:23
alleged there was a lack of safety
3:25
standards on set in your expertise from
3:27
what you've seen and heard what really
3:29
stood out to you where was The Real
3:31
miscarriage here and Justice of the
3:33
proper gun and the proper you know
3:35
weapon being provided to the proper
3:36
actor at the proper time
3:38
that's a great question you know I think
3:40
it really boils down to the armor I'm
3:43
not entirely sure that that vetting
3:45
process was as thorough as it could have
3:47
been and that might have been for many
3:48
reasons Chris you know from what I
3:50
understand it was a low budget sag indie
3:52
film and under that contract some things
3:54
get lost in in the mix you know they
3:56
tend to slip from the Wayside so there
3:58
there might not have have been protocol
4:00
during pre-production when they were
4:02
doing
4:03
um you know safety training during
4:04
rehearsals also you're not supposed to
4:06
have a gun during rehearsal and secondly
4:08
you're supposed to respect a 20-foot
4:10
rule which judging by the video footage
4:12
of that day I don't necessarily think it
4:14
was respected okay now let me ask you
4:16
both of this question here excuse my
4:18
ignorance on this but this is a movie
4:20
set why is there live rounds of
4:24
ammunition on a movie set well
4:28
the bottom line is it makes no sense and
4:32
that's why the the investigation where
4:34
is the investigation at this point the
4:36
missing the million dollar question here
4:39
is how did a live round get into that
4:41
gun in the first place and how do we not
4:43
know who put that live round into that
4:46
weapon because that is the real guilty
4:48
party and if anyone knowingly
4:49
intentionally put a live round in that
4:52
weapon well that could be a murder case
4:54
that and that's what I don't understand
4:55
I mean as an actor you're on a film set
4:57
why would you even think that there
4:59
would be a live round in there and I
5:01
guess you know that kind of goes to
5:02
exactly what you just said why is live
5:04
ammunition there who put the lobby
5:06
ammunition in that gun that's what they
5:09
really need to get to the bottom of
5:09
David let me know if you guys do this
5:10
there's a third person who the district
5:12
attorney names assistant director David
5:14
Halls now he's taken a plea deal for
5:16
negligent use of a deadly weapon how
5:18
could that impact the charges being
5:20
brought against Baldwin well I'm sure
5:22
he's going to testify you know for that
5:25
uh that guilty plea he may be testifying
5:28
as a witness for the state as well so
5:30
why I'll have to see how that all plays
5:32
out he seems to be the most culpable
5:34
yeah so now you have Alec Baldwin I
5:36
think both of you may have had a case
5:37
that you know maybe Alec Baldwin's not
5:40
that culpable here especially the
5:41
analysis that was just given so it seems
5:44
like this person is much more culpable
5:47
than Alec Baldwin or his co-defendant
5:49
and Laura it's been over a year since
5:51
this tragic event how have safety
5:53
protocols now changed on sets is it now
5:55
one of those things where there's just
5:56
so many different layers before a weapon
5:59
whether it's live or not not that it
6:01
should ever be live is placed in an
6:02
actor's hands yeah absolutely I mean
6:05
listen just to harken back to your point
6:06
under no circumstance should there be
6:08
live rounds on set yeah I just wrapped a
6:11
crime drama with with Steph no defray it
6:13
was co-produced by the Russo Brothers
6:15
um we made sure that we were working
6:17
with a licensed armor and that there
6:19
were absolutely under no circumstances
6:20
live rounds on set I think you know it
6:23
took a senseless tragedy to discover
6:24
that there are alternative options for
6:27
for firearms being put in films it's
6:28
something that you can settle in
6:30
post-production you you can use CGI
6:32
gunfire you know so it it has led to
6:36
other outcomes in that sense and David
6:38
I'm gonna give you the last 15 seconds
6:39
here what are the next steps for those
6:40
involved in this the next steps are that
6:43
there'll be an arraignment and we're
6:44
going to go through the discovery
6:46
process and there could be please and if
6:48
there's not if there's no plea in this
6:49
case then we're going to see a
6:50
blockbuster trial unbelievable all right
6:52
David Schwartz this is Lauren Pellegrini
6:54
thank you both for being here greatly
6:55
appreciate it good to see the two of you
6:57
thank you all right stay with cbs2 for
6:59
the very latest on the Chargers we'll
7:00
have more details as they come in and on
7:02
our website cbsnewyork.com and stay with
7:04
us we'll be right back