NY Trial Attorney David Schwartz, President of Gotham Government Relations ⁨@PIX11News⁩ Talking About The Diddy Verdict.

Gotham
In The News

At Gotham Government Relations, we take pride in staying ahead of the curve when it comes to policy developments and current events that impact our esteemed clientele and team members. "Gotham In The News" is your go-to page for comprehensive coverage of news articles and videos that directly pertain to our areas of expertise.

Youtube transcript
0:03 Right now at four, breaking news. A 0:05 split verdict in the Diddy sex 0:07 trafficking trial. Sean Diddy comes 0:09 acquitted of the most serious charges 0:11 but convicted of the lesser ones. In the 0:14 meantime, there's a lot to unpack in 0:15 this split verdict. So joining us now 0:18 are is our expert panel, New York trial 0:20 attorneys Dante Mills and David Schwarz. 0:23 Thank you both for both attorneys. Just 0:26
just get your quick reaction to this 0:27 verdict. Starting with you, David. I I 0:29 think it was the perfect verdict. I I've 0:31 been calling for this verdict all along. 0:33 This was not a sex trafficking case. 0:35 This was not a RICO case, but certainly 0:37 he was guilty of of of of moving of of 0:41 transferring prostitutes across state 0:44 lines, the man act for commercial 0:46 purposes. So, so certainly he was guilty 0:48 of that. 0:49
Yeah. I think what he was found guilty 0:51 of, it was pretty clear. And fairly 0:53 early on, I believe Shawn Combmes's 0:55 defense team told him, "We're gonna have 0:57 to sacrifice this charge for the other 1:00
charges." Because you saw Sean Comb's re 1:03 reaction when the verdict came out. He 1:05 said, "I love you. I'm coming home soon 1:07 to his family." So, they already walked 1:09 him through what would happen if he was 1:10 only convicted of the lesser charge. And 1:13 I think they said to save face, to save, 1:16 you know, our our our reputation, we're 1:19 gonna say yes, he used prostitutes, but 1:22 he did it as his personal pleasure. It 1:24 had nothing to do with Rico, and as long 1:26 as we get rid of those top charges, 1:28 we'll be okay. 1:29 All right. We want to also mention that 1:30 Anthony Dorenzo is also joining us. 1:32 He'll be live with us, chiming in on 1:34 this discussion. David, I want to ask 1:36 you about that more serious charge.
1:38 Rico, are you kind of surprised now that 1:40 they were hung up on this yesterday 1:41 given what we know now that with the no 1:43 guil not guilty and the sex trafficking? 1:45 You know, well, first of all, you never 1:46 know. Every jury is different and so you 1:49 don't know how many jurors were were 1:51 hung up on it could have just been a 1:52 couple. It could have been one. Uh I 1:54 would think the the majority of the
1:56 jurors, especially with the verdict 1:57 today, were not hung up on that charge 1:59 and understood that this was not the 2:01 mafia. This was not an organized 2:04 criminal enterprise. It was never from 2:06 the start. So the the prosecution 2:10 clearly overcharged this case and I 2:12 think the jury got it just right. 2:13
Yeah, that's my take on that. Was it a 2:15 waste of money? What happened here? 2:17 I don't know if it was a waste of money. 2:18 What happened is I think they prosecuted 2:19 the person. They saw this video of of
2:21 Shawn Holmes being physically abusive, 2:23 which is absolutely despicable. They 2:25 said something must be done about it. 2:27 Unfortunately, it was too late to charge 2:29 him with that. So they went on a hunt to 2:31 see what they could charge him with. And 2:33 I think that's what happened. and they 2:35 kind of lucked into the this charge of 2:37 prostitution. They tried to piece 2:39 together the other stuff, but it wasn't 2:40 enough there to really solidify it. And 2:42 what I hope happens now is that Shawn 2:45 Combmes isn't treated as if he was 2:47 guilty because he went through our 2:49 system and jurors said he didn't force 2:51 them. He didn't coers them to do 2:53 anything. He simply used prostitution 2:56 and that should be penalized a certain 2:58 way. I don't think anybody who was just 3:00 charged or found guilty of prostitution 3:02 was sent to jail for 10, 20 years. So, I 3:04 think those numbers should be off the 3:05 table. I hope the judge does a full, you 3:08 know, kind of reset and says this is 3:09 what he was charged with. Yes, but he 3:11 was only convicted of prostitution and 3:14 I'm going to penalize him just for that. 3:16 In the meantime, let's uh let's ask uh 3:18 DLO if he's still with us. Anthony, I'm 3:20 curious about one thing. Um because 3:22 you've been there in the court from the 3:24 very beginning of this trial on May 3:26 12th. How has Diddy's demeanor evolved 3:30 over the course of those seven weeks as 3:33 you've observed him there? 3:38 I'd say that it was pretty steadfast 3:40 throughout. He had the same demeanor of, 3:42 as I said before, being the CEO of his 3:45 legal team. He was very active in his 3:47 defense. He was not one to sit back and 3:50 keep his mouth shut. He was talking 3:52 constantly with his attorneys, passing 3:55 notes when there was testimony. There's 3:57 cross-examination. He was jogging 3:59 memories of his attorneys, giving them 4:02 suggestions of of different avenues to 4:04 explore with the witnesses on the stand. 4:06
He was constantly reading the evidence. 4:09 Uh he has glasses now. And we remarked 4:12 about what his his appearance looks like 4:13 in court, an older man. Uh he was really 4:17 always very much in tune with what was 4:20 going on. There were sometimes, however, 4:22 he got admonished by the judge because
4:24 he was a little bit too into it. uh 4:26 looking at the jury at times nodding 4:29 vigorously. He was one if he did not 4:31 agree or he did agree with something. 4:33 It's something that you very much knew 4:35
right off the bat how he was feeling. 4:37 His body language all along really told 4:39 the story. 4:41 Dante, I want to go back to something 4:42 you touched on just moments ago in 4:44 regards to moving forward. Your hope 4:46 that Diddy is only penalized for what he 4:49 is convicted of. How does that play into 4:51
whether or not he may receive bail now 4:53 versus before? Well, it plays into it 4:56 because he's char Well, he was found 4:59 guilty of prostitution and the judge 5:01 when the prosecutors came and said he 5:04
should be held in jail without bond 5:06 while he awaits sentencing, the judge 5:08 challenged the prosecution and said, 5:10 "Well, I need you to come back to me 5:11 with some some evidence or some proof 5:13 that people before who were only found 5:15 guilty of prosecution prostitution was 5:18 denied bond." That generally doesn't 5:20 happen. We're only talking about 5:22 prostitution here, which is nonviolent 5:24 crime. We can say yes, he was charged 5:26 with force and coercion, but he was 5:27 found not guilty on that kind of stuff. 5:29 So, will he just be treated for what he 5:31 was found guilty of is the question. 5:33 It's also interesting. I want to know if 5:35 he's going to speak at his sentencing 5:37 because he did not speak uh it looks 5:40 like he wanted to, but he didn't speak 5:41 at the trial sentencing. He has the 5:43 right to speak without being 5:44 cross-examined. So, we'll see if he 5:46 takes the stand, if he gives a 5:48 statement, if he apologizes, what his 5:50 demeanor is, then I think that's going 5:52 to be the next interesting thing. 5:53 He did speak briefly at the end, 5:55 thanking the judge for his hard work, 5:57
but not to the jury at all. But be you 5:59 think that he might speak today for this 6:02 for this hearing, but I think he'll be 6:04 prepped and ready to speak for his 6:05 sentencing. 6:06 Does he walk today? Look, the difference 6:08 in the federal system is to grant some 6:10 sort of bail package and and clearly it 6:14 it's a prostitution case. This is not a 6:15 murder case. So, I think the bail 6:18 package that the defense proposed is 6:20 very reasonable. And I believe the judge 6:23 will grant bail. 6:24 And how quickly do you suspect that 6:26 decision will take place? 6:27 Well, the judge said he'll let the he'll 6:28 let them know today. I don't think it's 6:29 fair to have somebody kind of just 6:30 hanging on. He said he'll let them know 6:31 today. I think the judge has a good idea 6:33 based on all the experience and these 6:36 types of cases. The judge has a good 6:38 idea of what he's going to do. 6:40 Let's go back to um to Anthony who was 6:42 out there. And Anthony, you mentioned 6:43 that uh when first got that note this 6:46 morning from uh from the jury. You 6:49 mentioned that the prosecutors had a 6:51 stoic look. What was the feeling like 6:54 inside of that courtroom for us? 7:00 Well, prosecutors obviously were not 7:02 pleased with the outcome of this. 7:04
However, they still did their best to 7:05 try and sway the judge with that bail 7:08 application in their letter and in court 7:10 saying, "Yes, these are still very 7:12 serious charges. These are federal 7:13 charges that he's been convicted of." 7:15 and the way he treated people, he should 7:17 not be allowed back, especially since 7:20 when he knew he was about to be 7:21 arrested, he came here to New York and 7:23 ultimately was ready for another 7:25 freakoff, they say. Something I do want 7:27 to clarify for you uh about the 7:29
logistics of the bail hearing when we 7:31 learn what the judge decides at 5:00. 7:34 From there, it takes only about a half 7:36 hour if he's granted bail for Diddy to 7:38 sign that paperwork. Since the 7:40 guaranters are already in the building, 7:42 it won't take long at all. The Diddy 7:45 team tells me that the attorneys will
7:46 definitely be speaking outside of the 7:48 courthouse after that process. And if 7:51 Diddy is granted bail, he himself will 7:54 appear at the podium as well. 7:57 David, that's interesting. 7:58 Yeah, David, can we ask you about that? 8:00 If he is granted bail, what could the 8:02 conditions look like as far as his 8:03 release? 8:04 Well, they they could limit uh where 8:06 he's going to be. I think he wants to be 8:08 in the state of Florida at his mansion 8:10 in Florida. They could take his 8:11 passport. They could um they could tell 8:14 him, you know, you have to live a very 8:16 law-abiding life. No drugs, no alcohol, 8:19 no freakoffs, none of this nonsense. So, 8:22 uh they could put there there there's 8:25 there's they're very liberal with what 8:27 bail conditions there could be, but I 8:29 think whatever the bail conditions are, 8:31 he's he's going to go along with it. 8:33 They can test to see if you've had 8:34 alcohol or drugs. They can't test to see
8:36 if you had a free butud. 8:40 What the judge is going to consider is 8:42 is he a threat to society if he gets out 8:45 right now. The prosecution is going to 8:46 say, well, maybe he may try and 8:48 influence some witnesses, but that part 8:49 of the case is over. And then the other 8:51 aspect is will he show up or will he try 8:53 to flee? And because now he doesn't have 8:56 a mandatory minimum sentence, he'll 8:58
probably be in jail for a shorter time. 8:59 The likelihood of that is slim to none. 9:01 So, he's facing a myriad myriad of 9:03 lawsuits right now from a number of 9:05 different people. What does today's 9:07 verdict do to many of those cases? 9:09 I think it makes those cases weaker 9:11 because the jury here, although they
9:13 only considered two people, right, 9:15 Cassie Vento and Jane, the jury here 9:17 said there was no force or coercion. And 9:20 although he committed the crime of 9:22 prostitution, which is technically 9:24
illegal, everybody was willing 9:25 participants. So, you can't sue someone 9:28 civily for something you willingly 9:29 participated in. So, I think this kind 9:31 of emboldens his defense against those 9:33 civil cases. 9:34 I'm going to push back a little. We have 9:35 to disagree on something, right? So, so 9:38 that in in a civil case, it's a much 9:40 lower standard, right? It's just 9:41 prepoundonderance of the evidence. It's
9:43 just this balancing. So, clearly they 9:45 didn't have proof beyond a reasonable 9:47 doubt, which is the standard in a 9:48 criminal case. So, a civil case much 9:51 lower standard. There's definitely um 9:54 causes of action here that have been 9:56 brought in the civil arena and I think 9:58 it'll be an easier time to to show him 10:02 to show that he's liable for a civil 10:04 case rather than convicted on a criminal 10:06 case. 10:06
All right, gentlemen. We're going to 10:08 have to leave it there. Dante, David, 10:09 thank you guys for this process as well 10:12 as DLO. It's all the the D did D did D 10:14 did D did D did D did D did D did D did 10:14
D did Dy do Dante David? 10:18 We need to change our name. 10:19 I know exactly. Thank you guys all for
10:21 being here and your analysis.