NY Criminal Defense Attorney David Schwartz ⁨@PIX11News⁩ Talking About Diddy's Trafficking Trial

Gotham
In The News

At Gotham Government Relations, we take pride in staying ahead of the curve when it comes to policy developments and current events that impact our esteemed clientele and team members. "Gotham In The News" is your go-to page for comprehensive coverage of news articles and videos that directly pertain to our areas of expertise.

Youtube transcript
0:01 escorts rappers and recording artists. 0:04 Explosive testimony this week in the sex 0:07 trafficking trial of Shaun Diddy 0:09 Combmes. Pix 11 talking exclusively to 0:12 an escort named the Punisher just after 0:15 testifying he wouldn't have taken part 0:17 in the freakoffs if he thought Diddy was 0:20 forcing his ex Cassie Ventura. I can't 0:23 say that any part of my experience gave 0:26 me any cues that this was a woman in 0:28 distress. more of a fetish type of 0:30 scenario. Cassy's mother also 0:32 testifying, saying Col threatened to 0:35 release sex tapes of her daughter if she 0:37 didn't pay him $20,000. 0:40 And prosecutors calling Diddy's former 0:42 assistants to the stand as they try to 0:44 paint the picture of Diddy running a 0:47 criminal enterprise. But will the jury 0:49 see it that way? If someone has their 0:51 staff aiding to bet them doing something 0:53 that makes them a racketeering 0:54 enterprise, negative does not. 0:58 And that was just some of the most 1:00 dramatic testimony this week in the 1:02 Shaun Diddy Combmes trial. Yeah, Pix 1:04 11's Anthony Dorenzo has been in court 1:06 all week with us. He joins us now. But 1:09 also joining us are New York City trial 1:10 attorney David Schwarz and entertainment 1:12 and lifestyle reporter Jasmine Simpkins 1:15 who has also been covering the trial. 1:17 Thank you all for being here. Anthony, 1:18 let's talk start with you. What's your 1:21 biggest takeaway from this week? Well, 1:23
there was such a mixed bag, but of 1:25 course, the kid cuddy testimony was what 1:27 everyone was talking about because he 1:29 really went to the racketeering element 1:31 of it. And one of the predicate acts 1:33
that you have to prove with uh the RICO 1:37 conspiracy is that there was arson 1:39 involved. So, he specifically talked 1:41 about when his vehicle was blown up uh 1:44 when he was dating Cassie back in 2011,
1:47 2012. He also talked about the threats 1:50 that were made. Uh he talked about 1:52 someone that they both knew mutually 1:54 that possibly was threatening Kid Cuddy. 1:57 And so he talked all about these things 1:59 that really talked really based on the 2:02 enterprise is what prosecutors are 2:05 trying to prove. Interesting. David, 2:07 let's talk to you a little bit about 2:09 this as far as the prosecution is 2:10 concerned. We're in week two. Still a 2:12 long way to go as far as this trial. Um, 2:14 but do you think the prosecution has
2:16 really landed with the charges here or 2:19 does this present itself as being very 2:21 much a domestic violence case? 2:24 Like you said, it's only week three of a 2:27 of an 8week trial, but as of this moment 2:29
in time, they have not proven any type 2:32 of enterprise existed. I'm sure we're 2:35 going to be hearing evidence later on in 2:37 the coming weeks about an enterprise, 2:39 but right now, you know, and and the
2:42 underlying acts that make up this this 2:44 corruption, you don't have to prove the 2:47 underlying acts. You just have to show 2:49 that there was an agreement amongst the 2:51 co-conspirators to commit the underlying 2:53 acts. So, as of this moment in time, I 2:56 don't see how the prosecution has proven 2:59
their case right now. Yeah, but it is 3:01 really, really early. Jasmine, to you, 3:02 we're so happy to have you. Um, you've 3:04 been covering entertainment for quite 3:05 some time right now. You've interviewed 3:07
Diddy and Cassie several times. Has this 3:11 trial so far given you some context to 3:13 some of your interactions with those 3:15 two? Oh my gosh, I love that you use 3:17 that word context because I remember 3:19 being in the courtroom last week hearing 3:22 Cassie's testimony and thinking to 3:24 myself, "Oh my goodness, I had no idea, 3:27 none of us had any idea what she was 3:29 going through during that time." But to 3:31 have interviewed her on March 4th, the 3:34 day before the viral video that we've 3:36 now seen in the Intercontinental Hotel, 3:38 to know that she was undergoing such a 3:40 dark, crazy time in her life whilst also 3:44 promoting a film. And then just a few 3:47 days later, I talked to her again on the 3:48 red carpet after the incident has 3:50 happened. And she's jovial. She's 3:53 laughing, but her entire body is covered 3:55 in like bronze, you know, um, looks like 3:58 she had gotten a a severe spray tan. And 4:01 I remember commenting to her, I was 4:02 like, "Gosh, you look like a blond a 4:04 bombshell, this bronze bombshell, 4:06 because I had just seen her days 4:08 earlier." So, just little nuggets like 4:10
that over the years, speaking with Shawn 4:12 numerous times, not knowing that this is 4:15 a man that has created this amazing 4:17 enterprise. So much much great music has 4:20 come out of Bad Boy. I mean, he coined 4:21 this term black excellence. To know that 4:24 behind the scenes, behind this huge 4:27 empire and all the great things that he 4:28 had been doing, that he was living this 4:31 dark, very demented almost um lifestyle. 4:35 It just made me wonder what is going on 4:37 in the underbelly of Hollywood and we 4:38
think we know these celebrities and 4:40 what's going on and we have no they 4:42 focused a lot of time on that testimony 4:45 surrounding the Intercontinental Hotel 4:47 incident and the defense really was 4:51
picking apart Cassie at that moment 4:53 because they were bringing up her text 4:54 messages to Shawn Combmes around that 4:56 time where she was the one who wanted to 4:59 freak off. They said she was the one who 5:02 inspired that Intercontinental Hotel 5:04 stay. Uh when ultimately she was then 5:08 trying to flee from it because he had 5:10 found something out. She was trying to 5:13 leave that situation. But this was a 5:15 period when her movie was about to come 5:17 out. She was on the red carpet when she 5:19 was being interviewed uh just there. And 5:21 she told Shawn, you know, I really want 5:24 this to be a really special time in my 5:26 life. I want to make sure that all of 5:28 this is going to go perfectly. And she 5:31 said the reason why she wanted to freak 5:33 off was to satisfy him so that she 5:36 didn't have any problems surrounding 5:37 that premiere. But ultimately, you can 5:40 see how volatile the relationship was 5:42 because they still did have a major 5:45 incident where she had to cover herself 5:46 up and make up. Yeah, understandable. 5:48 Okay, David, we want to get back to you 5:50 and some of these witnesses. We know
5:51 that the defense did not even question 5:52 Cassie's mom, but do you feel that there 5:54 are any witnesses that we've seen so far 5:56 that have kind of benefited either the 5:58 prosecution or the defense?
6:01 Well, you know, as to the arson, you 6:04 know, the arson really fell flat because 6:06 the there was no proof at all that shown 6:09 that Shawn Combmes actually committed 6:11 the arson, which is certainly one of the 6:13 underlying crimes that they're trying to 6:16 show. And again, they don't have to 6:17 prove the underlying crimes, but that 6:20 they still have to make a showing that 6:22 there was an agreement to commit this 6:23 underlying crime. So, a couple of 6:25 problems there. Number one, you don't 6:27 know if Shawn Combmes committed the 6:29 arson. And number two, who did he have 6:31 the agreement with to commit this arson? 6:34 Remember, this is an enterprise. This is 6:36 this is a criminal enterprise that 6:38
they're trying to prove. And right now, 6:41 the you know, it's it's falling flat at 6:44 this moment in time. That's not to say 6:46 that there'll be more evidence in the 6:48 coming weeks. And Jasmine, you, as I 6:50
mentioned, you've been covering 6:50 entertainment for quite a bit out there 6:53 in Los Angeles. What go back to what you 6:56 were um leading to. What does this case 6:59 tell you about the greater entertainment 7:01 industry? 7:03 As I was saying, I think it really makes 7:04 us question a lot of us journalists. We 7:06 think we know these celebrities that we 7:08 talk to day in and day out and we really 7:10
have no idea what's going on behind the 7:12 scenes. What other lives they're 7:14 leading? Are they living these dual 7:16 lives like Shawn Combmes? Are there 7:18 people on their staff, people that are 7:20 working with them that are helping them 7:22 cover up um this other personality, this 7:25 other side of their life that in some 7:27 ways and and what we're finding with him 7:29 was extremely criminal. Um and in the 7:32 coming weeks, I think we're going to 7:33 finally hear from some of those folks. I 7:34 mean they brought up his chief of staff 7:37 assistant Christina Cororum DRock who 7:39 was with him for a very very long time 7:40 as his security. I've seen him with 7:42 DRock for many years. You kind of over 7:44 the last 10 years have seen some of the 7:46 same faces working around him. So I 7:48 think as this trial unfolds, we'll also 7:50 get a chance to to hear from them and 7:52 find out what the heck has been going 7:54 on. 7:55 So, we're talking about this Enterprise 7:58 and they've been calling witnesses up to 8:00 the to the stand that worked for Diddy 8:02 and we're going to continue to see that 8:04 next week. The Enterprise, of course, 8:05 people who worked under him. And we 8:07 heard from two assistants this past week 8:09 who were allegedly committing crimes 8:12 while they were working for Diddy, which 8:14 is why one of them was said he wasn't 8:16 going to testify unless that he was 8:18 guaranteed immunity. Oh, wow. Because he 8:21 was carrying large sums of cash. He was 8:24 buying drugs for Diddy. Uh, and he was 8:27 sitting idly by as these violent acts 8:30 went on. So, he said he was going to 8:32 plead the fifth unless the judge granted 8:35 him immunity and that's what happened. 8:36 Take us inside the courtroom. What is it 8:38 like? What does it feel like? How quiet 8:40 is it? Do you get to see the jurors at 8:42 all? Yeah, I see the jurors and playing. 8:45
So, they it depends. I think one of the 8:48 most interesting things was at the end 8:50 of Cassie's testimony, they all started 8:51 to seem really bored. The all the energy 8:54 kind of really feel felt like it was 8:56 sucked out of the room at that point. 8:57 She was on the stand for a combined 24 9:00 hours, I counted. So, even she was 9:03 feeling the weight of all of this 9:04 testimony, but they seemed to kind of 9:06 want to move on from that. Uh they had 9:09 some moments of levity when Kid Cuddy 9:11 was on the stand yesterday uh when he 9:13 was talking about his interaction with 9:15 Shawn on the phone and the the colorful 9:18 language that he used with him. Uh at 9:20 one point he called him that Marvel 9:22 super villain and they they broke out 9:24 into laughter. But Diddy is very very 9:27 much an active defendant. He is working 9:30
with his attorneys all the time, 9:32 speaking with them, passing them notes. 9:34 So he's he's very much involved. All 9:36 right. Uh David to you who won the week. 9:41 The defense won the week because of the
9:43 presumption of innocence and and the 9:46 prosecution has to prove guilt beyond a 9:48 reasonable doubt. And I think everything 9:50 right now is falling a little flat. 9:52 Certainly they proved a domestic 9:54
violence case. They pro they proved that 9:57 he has done horrible things and vicious 10:00 attacks. But that's not what this case 10:02 is about. This case is about this 10:04 criminal enterprise, which the statue
10:07 was basically made when it when trying 10:09 to prosecute the mafia way back when. 10:12 And the fact that he put together this 10:14 enterprise, I just don't see it yet. 10:17 Jasmine, before we let you go, there's 10:19 kind of been this unspoken rule in the 10:21 entertainment industry that you don't 10:23 talk badly about Diddy. Do you think 10:25 after this trial that changes for many 10:27 people? Oh god. Yeah. And I think little 10:29 by little you're you're starting to see 10:31 people distance themselves or at least 10:33
come out and say, "Hey, listen. I've 10:35 never been to a Diddy party. I've never 10:36 seen these things. I didn't experience a 10:38 freakoff." I think people really really 10:40 because I mean, you've had everyone from 10:42 Marthur Stewart to Donald Trump to Oprah 10:44 and and and all kinds of folks in 10:46 between who have been at these white 10:47 parties. I mean, he kind of put the 10:49 Hampton's on the map in terms of the 10:50 hip-hop culture at one point in time. 10:52 So, he's touched so many parts of the 10:54 entertainment industry and had so many10:56 friends that I I feel like even more 10:59 people are going to be making sure as 11:00 more things come out in this trial that 11:02 they distance themselves from him. All
11:04 right, Jasmine and David, thank you so 11:06 much. And we'll be right back with more 11:08 of our coverage of Diddy's trial. Yeah. 11:11 Up next, a look at what's happening in 11:13 court next week. Anthony will be with 11:15 us.